The Atlas of Human Meaning

Cited chronology · Uncertainty preserved

When do these texts enter the record?

Compare composition and earliest written-attestation windows without converting scholarly ranges into false precision.

47 text chronology assertions
Temporal overlap is not evidence of contact, borrowing, ancestry, or influence. Those require separate, cited relationship claims.

Where do the windows cluster and overlap?

Band width reflects the full derived bounds of each cited date bucket. Dashed outlines mark disputed chronology; blue bands are attestations rather than composition claims.

  • Approximate composition
  • Disputed date
  • Written attestation
Composition and attestation windows for Atlas textsHorizontal bands show cited time windows. Wider bands mean coarser or longer date ranges; dashed outlines mark disputed dates.The Epic of GilgameshAtra-ḫasīsLudlul bēl nēmeqiBook of DocumentsFirst SamuelGenesisKaṭha UpaniṣadLeviticusŚatapatha BrāhmaṇaOdysseyBook of JobĀcārāṅga SūtraAnalectsDhammapadaGreat LearningAristotle, PoliticsNicomachean EthicsPhaedoPlato, RepublicLetter to MenoeceusEpicurean Principal DoctrinesZhuangziDaodejingMenciusSūtrakṛtāṅgaUttarādhyayana SūtraBhagavad GītāAṅguttara NikāyaItivuttakaMajjhima NikāyaSaṃyutta NikāyaSutta NipātaThe Library of Pseudo-Apollod…First Epistle to the Corinthi…Epistle to the HebrewsGospel of JohnDiscourses of EpictetusEncheiridion (Handbook) of Ep…Outlines of PyrrhonismMeditationsConfessionsQur'anGospel of MatthewGroundwork for the Metaphysic…On LibertyUtilitarianismUtilitarianism

Dates, uncertainty, and sources

The table is the complete semantic alternative to the chart. Existing prose dating remains in each text record; these structured assertions make sorting and visualization possible.

All published text chronology assertions
TextAssertionWindowCertainty and caveatTradition contextSources
The Epic of GilgameshCompositionLate 2nd millennium BCEApproximateAncient Mesopotamian religion
  • George, The Babylonian Gilgamesh Epic · Draft
Atra-ḫasīsComposition17th century BCE Old Babylonian recensionApproximateAncient Mesopotamian religion
  • Lambert and Millard's Atra-ḫasīs edition · Draft
Ludlul bēl nēmeqiCompositionKassite period; anchored near the reign of Nazi-Maruttaš (c. 1307–1282 BCE)Disputed
A royal mention supplies a historical anchor but does not prove an exact composition interval.
Ancient Mesopotamian religion
  • Lambert, Babylonian Wisdom Literature (1960) · Draft
Book of DocumentsComposition11th-3rd century BCE (disputed)Disputed
Layering, excavation, and later transmission make precise date boundaries contested across the textual tradition.
Confucianism
  • Nylan, The Five Confucian Classics (2001) · Draft · chronology chapter
First SamuelComposition10th-6th century BCE traditions and redaction (disputed)Disputed
The 1 Samuel 8-12 sequence is textually composite, so single-date assertions about its political theory should be treated as periodized claims.
Judaism
  • McCarthy, The Inauguration of Monarchy in Israel · Draft · 1 Samuel 8-12
GenesisCompositionLayered composition and editing across the 1st millennium BCEDisputed
Different materials and editorial stages are dated differently.
Judaism
  • Carr, Precursors to the Flood Narrative · Draft
Kaṭha UpaniṣadCompositionMid-to-late 1st millennium BCEDisputed
Exact date, strata, and relationship to other renunciant currents remain disputed.
Hinduism
  • Olivelle, The Early Upaniṣads · Draft
LeviticusCompositionComposition and editing across the 1st millennium BCEDisputed
Priestly materials and the Holiness collection may reflect different periods.
Judaism
  • Milgrom, Leviticus 17–22 · Draft
Śatapatha BrāhmaṇaCompositionLayered composition in the 1st millennium BCEDisputed
The text contains layers whose internal chronology remains debated.
Vedic religion
  • Eggeling's Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa · Draft
OdysseyCompositionLate 8th–early 7th century BCEApproximateAncient Greek religion
  • Murray, Odyssey (1919) · Draft
Book of JobCompositionc. 6th–4th century BCEDisputed
The poetic dialogues, prose frame, and final form may have different histories.
Judaism
  • Newsom, The Book of Job (2003) · Draft
Ācārāṅga SūtraCompositionOlder strata conventionally placed in the mid-1st millennium BCEDisputed
The two books and their redaction are layered; this wide band is an orientation, not a single composition date.
Jainism
  • Dundas, The Jains · Draft
  • Wiley, Historical Dictionary of Jainism · Draft
AnalectsComposition5th-3rd century BCEDisputed
Authorship and compilation phases are disputed because the text is anthologized from earlier sayings.
Confucianism
  • Slingerland, Confucius: Analects · Draft
DhammapadaCompositionEarly Buddhist period; collection by roughly the 3rd century BCEDisputed
Individual verses may be earlier than the anthology, and the collection date is debated.
Buddhism
  • Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (1998) · Draft
Great LearningComposition5th-2nd century BCE (disputed)Disputed
The received text was transmitted as a Book of Rites chapter and later reorganized by Zhu Xi; the dating and extent of earlier layers remain disputed.
Confucianism
  • Gardner, The Four Books · Draft · historical introduction
Aristotle, PoliticsComposition4th century BCE (composition and redaction history disputed)Disputed
The exact sequence of lecture notes and editorial compilation for the Politics text is not settled.
Aristotelianism
  • Kraut, Aristotle: Political Philosophy · Draft
Nicomachean EthicsComposition4th century BCE (compilation and redaction debated)Disputed
The transmission history is debated regarding when Aristotle's lecture notes were editorially finalized.
Aristotelianism
  • Kraut, Aristotle's Ethics · Draft
PhaedoComposition4th century BCEDisputed
The dialogue is commonly assigned to Plato's middle period, but exact dating is disputed.
Platonism
  • Ebrey, Plato's Phaedo · Draft
Plato, RepublicComposition4th century BCE (exact date disputed)Disputed
The dialogue is usually placed in Plato's middle period, but its exact date and whether it underwent meaningful revision remain disputed.
Platonism
  • Annas, Introduction to Plato's Republic · Draft · Introduction
  • Schofield, Plato: Political Philosophy · Draft · introduction
Letter to MenoeceusComposition4th-3rd century BCEApproximateEpicureanism
  • Konstan, Epicurus · Draft
Epicurean Principal DoctrinesComposition4th-3rd century BCEApproximateEpicureanism
  • Konstan, Epicurus · Draft
ZhuangziComposition4th-3rd century BCE (layered transmission)Disputed
Compilation and redaction history is debated; this point reflects the best-supported conservative window.
Early Daoist philosophy
  • Legge, Writings of Kwang-tze (The Texts of Taoism, Part I) · Draft · introductory matter
  • Ziporyn, Zhuangzi: Essential Writings · Draft · composition and transmission
DaodejingCompositionc. 4th-2nd century BCEApproximate
Textual stratification is debated; later canonicalization is strong enough to affect received chapter order.
Early Daoist philosophy
  • Legge, Tao Te Ching (The Texts of Taoism, Part I) · Draft · editorial note on recension
  • Hansen, Daoism · Draft · dating summary
MenciusCompositionCore teachings likely 4th–3rd century BCE with substantial later editorial layeringDisputed
Scholars diverge on the dating window for specific book-level layers; modern scholarship treats the received text as a stratified tradition.
Confucianism
  • Van Norden, Mengzi · Draft
  • Pines, The Everlasting Empire · Draft · textual transmission
SūtrakṛtāṅgaCompositionLayered mid-to-late 1st-millennium BCE materialDisputed
Relative strata, oral transmission, and later commentary prevent a single secure composition date.
Jainism
  • Dundas, The Jains · Draft
  • Wiley, Historical Dictionary of Jainism · Draft
Uttarādhyayana SūtraCompositionComposite late-1st-millennium BCE to early-CE anthologyDisputed
Individual lectures differ in age; the band describes compilation uncertainty rather than dating every verse alike.
Jainism
  • Dundas, The Jains · Draft
  • Wiley, Historical Dictionary of Jainism · Draft
Bhagavad GītāCompositionc. 2nd century BCE–2nd century CEDisputed
The work is layered and its date and final form remain debated.
Hinduism
  • Malinar, The Bhagavadgita: Doctrines and Contexts · Draft
Aṅguttara NikāyaAttestationCommitted to writing c. 1st century BCE after oral transmissionApproximateBuddhism
  • Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (1998) · Draft
ItivuttakaAttestationWritten transmission by c. 1st century BCEApproximateBuddhism
  • Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (1998) · Draft
Majjhima NikāyaAttestationCommitted to writing c. 1st century BCE after oral transmissionApproximateBuddhism
  • Collins, Nirvana: Concept, Imagery, Narrative · Draft
Saṃyutta NikāyaAttestationCommitted to writing c. 1st century BCE after oral transmissionApproximateBuddhism
  • Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (1998) · Draft
Sutta NipātaAttestationPāli Canon committed to writing c. 1st century BCE after oral transmissionApproximateBuddhism
  • Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (1998) · Draft
The Library of Pseudo-ApollodorusComposition1st–2nd century CEApproximateAncient Greek religion
  • Frazer's Apollodorus · Draft
First Epistle to the CorinthiansCompositionc. 53–55 CEApproximateChristianity
  • Cook, The Enspirited Body in 1 Corinthians 15 · Draft
Epistle to the HebrewsCompositionc. 60–100 CEDisputed
Authorship and exact date are uncertain.
Christianity
  • Martin, Old Testament Foundations for Christian Hospitality · Draft
Gospel of JohnCompositionc. 90–110 CEDisputed
The Gospel's composition history and final date remain debated.
Christianity
  • Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (1966) · Draft
Discourses of EpictetusCompositionEarly 2nd century CEApproximateStoicism
  • Long, Epictetus: A Stoic and Socratic Guide to Life · Draft
Encheiridion (Handbook) of EpictetusCompositionEarly 2nd century CEApproximateStoicism
  • Long, Epictetus: A Stoic and Socratic Guide to Life · Draft
Outlines of PyrrhonismComposition2nd–3rd century CEDisputed
The work's attribution to Sextus is stable; Sextus's lifetime and the exact order of his writings remain uncertain.
Pyrrhonism
  • Vogt, Sextus Empiricus · Draft · textual-historical profile
  • Bett, Pyrrho, his Antecedents, and his Legacy · Draft · transmission history
MeditationsCompositionCommonly dated to AD 170–180 as campaign-era and court-period composition; exact dating remains debated.Disputed
The conventional range is approximate; individual notes are not securely dated.
Stoicism
  • Hadot, Inner Citadel · Draft
ConfessionsCompositionc. 397–400 CEApproximateChristianity
  • Komline, Augustine on the Will · Draft
Qur'anCompositionc. 610–632 CE in Muslim tradition; codified in the mid-7th centuryApproximate
The displayed interval follows traditional revelation chronology; scholarship distinguishes revelation, collection, and codification questions.
Islam
  • Johns, Qur'anic presentation of Job (1999) · Draft
  • Pickthall, The Meaning of the Glorious Koran (1930) · Draft
Gospel of MatthewCompositionc. 70–100 CE (proposals vary)Disputed
The range preserves disagreement over the gospel's final composition and redaction rather than selecting one proposed year.
Christianity
  • Davies and Allison, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Matthew, vol. 1 · Draft
  • Ulrich Luz, Matthew 1–7: A Commentary · Draft
Groundwork for the Metaphysics of MoralsPublication1785ExactKantian ethics
  • Abbott, Kant, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysic of Morals · Draft
On LibertyPublication1859ExactUtilitarianism
  • Mill, On Liberty (1859) · Draft
UtilitarianismPublicationSerialized in 1861ExactUtilitarianism
  • Mill, Utilitarianism (1863) · Draft
UtilitarianismPublicationPublished in book form in 1863ExactUtilitarianism
  • Mill, Utilitarianism (1863) · Draft